With multiple sclerosis, do you view your glass as half-full or half-empty?
For this columnist, a blend of outlooks is key

When presented with a drinking glass containing half the water it can hold, a pessimist would say that it’s half-empty while an optimist would say that the glass is half-full. A realist would probably demand to know who drank half of their water, and an idealist might simply be grateful that there was some water left and make the best of it.
I don’t think that anyone embodies just one of those personalities all the time, although I’ve met some people who make me question that theory. Others definitely seem to have a favorite, but I believe life consists of a blend of those states. I know that my life with multiple sclerosis (MS) certainly does.
MS is easy to be pessimistic about. After all, what’s to like? It’s a lifelong disease with no cure, and the symptoms are debilitating, unpredictable, and sometimes invisible. There isn’t any part of my life that MS doesn’t touch, and its touch is never gentle. While there aren’t as many as there were at the beginning, there are still plenty of moments when I look at what’s missing from my life and think that my cup is half-empty.
I suppose I could choose to feel like that all the time, but I try to balance it out with a healthy dose of optimism. I have plenty in my life that would lead me to consider my glass to be half-full. For one, I have a very supportive family, understanding friends, and a great network of others with MS that I can reach out to.
Two, there are new treatments for both the disease and its symptoms being developed all the time, so there’s a chance the future will be bright.
The first is present fact while the second is future hope. Hope is a sort of optimism, fed by idealism, and needs to be tempered with realism.
Idealism tells me that a new discovery or proposed therapy has the potential to be groundbreaking. Realism reminds me that the process takes years, from concept to reality, and is statistically more likely to fail than to succeed. I have no intention of letting go of my idealism. I’ve written before that, for most of my life, I was taught that hope is not a course of action. Well, with MS it is — as long as it’s realistic hope.
I might have considered it this way at one time, but now I don’t think that this is an either-or situation. I believe that you can be pessimistic, optimistic, idealistic, and realistic about MS. I also believe that the first three are held together and strengthened by the last one.
If you have realistic pessimism, realistic optimism, and even realistic idealism, then, in my opinion, you have achieved a healthy blend of outlooks.
I brought up these four outlooks in the first paragraph along with the well-known water glass analogy, but what about an opportunist? In that scenario, the opportunist would probably say, “While you guys were busy arguing about whether the glass was half-full or half-empty, I snuck in and drank all your water.”
I’m sure there’s a lesson about MS there, too, but I couldn’t find it. If you know one involving realistic opportunism, please share it in the comments.
Note: Multiple Sclerosis News Today is strictly a news and information website about the disease. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website. The opinions expressed in this column are not those of Multiple Sclerosis News Today or its parent company, Bionews, and are intended to spark discussion about issues pertaining to multiple sclerosis.
Yolande Sander
A friend gave me a great ompliment the other day. He said: "Every time your glass seems half-full, you just go and re-fill it! How do you manage that?"
I do believe that a bad day is there to better prepare me for whatever MS throws at me.
Benjamin Hofmeister
Wow! That was a great comment. Thank you so much for sharing it!
Lisa Kandel
I used to be more pessimistic about my MS, but I feel extremely hopeful now. I have Jesus in my heart, and he helps me get through anything and everything. I definitely have my bad days, but he gives me hope. The good days are kind of few and far, but Jesus makes them bearable always.
Stay blessed and be a blessing!
Benjamin Hofmeister
Thank you for your beautiful words Lisa! I'm definitely blessed and hope and pray that I'm passing on those blessings.
sivan
I feel half emptiness most of time as it a disease which doesn't let us live or doesn't kill us.
Benjamin Hofmeister
I hear you and they're have been plenty of those moments since diagnosis and will be more to come in the future. There are times when I want to shout at multiple sclerosis and tell it to give me All or Nothing instead of this halfway between existence.
This is a very hard disease to see as anything but half empty. It's my family and friends that keep me feeling half full though.
ANNE
absolutely half full i am in control of my life and i am very hopeful! happiness is in not control not MS
Benjamin Hofmeister
Thanks for that Anne! I definitely have my moments of pessimism, but like you, I think the healthiest place for me to be is as a realistic optimist.
Darien Provence
Greetings! Well, if a group of people were sitting around debating the status of a partially full glass of water. And if, in that group there was a realistic opportunist, it might be possible that he would sit there, listening to the chatter, vaguely bored because really, this is exactly the kind of discussion that never gets resolved. But if that person also became thirsty he probably would just drink the water and figure ‘Oh well, at least they now have something else to talk about that does have an answer.
I hope that came out as funny written as it was in my head. 😁
Benjamin Hofmeister
Don't worry Darien, it did!
Rob M.
Not trying to be flippant here, or fill your comment section with cliches, but we must all remember things can always be worse. We all are given burdens to bear in this brief life (and it goes by fast)! Some burdens are worse than others. Faith is the foundation of any optimism I have, that, & the people I love.
Benjamin Hofmeister
Hi Rob, that was not flippant at all. I always think of an old Calvin and Hobbes strip where Calvin's dad tells him that things could be worse and Calvin replies that they could be better too.
You are so right. We all have burdens to bear and some are invisible. Where I have to be careful is thinking that because someone else's burden looks heavier or lighter than mine, it doesn't invalidate either of our experiences.
Thanks for the comment. It is definitely something we all need to consider.
Teens
My cup's not just full, it’s doing the Macarena and spilling everywhere. So when someone tells me their cup is half empty (or bone dry), I smile and ask, “Well then… who’s hogging the tap?” It usually makes them pause, think, and maybe even laugh before realising, "Oh wait, maybe I can do something about this".
Benjamin Hofmeister
If I ever bring up the Macarena, my kids ask if that's something I did in the late 1900s. LOL.
I really like your idea of a glass being half full because our ailment has made us spill half of it. I wish I'd thought of that before I turned in that column.
Nancy
I gotta glass, that is what makes me happy!
Benjamin Hofmeister
I do too Nancy LOL! Fortunately, mine is heavy lead crystal so I can throw it at any opportunists.
Leanne Broughton
My attitude changes with my moods. I am not depressed but have times I feel maudllin thinking about what I would or had planned to do in retirement and cannot physically manage anymore. Then I am happy and have had a good day spent with friends or family. So I can go both ways in life.
Benjamin Hofmeister
Hi Leanne! I actually have a column in the works about how MS has changed my future plans.... or really about how difficult it is to make future plans when you have MS.
I wouldn't say that I ever had a bucket list per se, but I did have a number of things that I wanted to do in retirement and MS changed all that.